Well, I think that your son might like to have a matching stocking to his girlfriends. Make two of the new style, they are fabulous! Who knows, maybe they will someday marry and hang them in their home together.
Your original one is gorgeous. Right now I'm going through the same thoughts with my son's new girlfriend he has given a little promise ring to and what to do about a stocking for her. Will check back to read what the cuties advise is. I like your embroidered one just as much. Both are lovely.
This one is absolutely beautiful but I would go with a new one too. It's been a while so give him and her both a treat!
This one in the picture is beautiful. But, I'm inclined to think that a new one for your son, and perhaps a matching one for his girlfriend is probably the way to go.
this is the style I do now with embroidery, I am really in a fog on which to do.