Well, I have a Hoop-It-All, but I don't have either of those machines. As for rating the Hoop-It-All, it is fairly good. The major drawback, in my opinion, is that it is supposed to use sticky-backed stabilizer to hold your project in place, and that can gum up your needles and stuff while you work. I've had a bit of success using tape and cut-away stabilizers, but even then, there is still the sticky mess left behind on the hoop. Hope that helps you decide what you are going to do.