We also have a tough, tough decision about the dog we got for Ben. It's been two years now that we got Bia, the black lab (not pure bred, but nearly) for Ben. She had a sad history, but I really thought I could turn her into a service dog. She just has too many hang-ups from her past, mostly the starving part. She will trample anyone to get at food, including Ben. She would chase a squirrel and drag Ben, except he is good at dropping the leash. She still won't take a treat gently and always involves her teeth.
She's probably 6 years old and is still a strong, exuberant dog, and her greeting behaviors are still hard to control. I have wrecked my shoulder training her - and to tell the truth she doesn't seem very smart.
She continually puts her paw on people, which we have nearly extinguished.
We have made lots of progress. She doesn't growl at men any longer. She is house trained. She doesn't dig. She goes outside (into the forest) and comes back in right away. She loves her toys. She doesn't chew on furniture.
Ben loves her. He pets her on the head and says, "Bia, I love you." and she wags her tail at him.
But, the worst thing of all is she nips at people. She doesn't actually bite. She just pokes at them with her teeth. She has done this four times. Does this mean she will bite? It's always when they arrive. It's never been Ben.
Should we be thinking of having her put down? Do dogs that nip become dogs that bite?
I'd sure appreciate some input from people who know dogs.
Thanks, Jan
It is sooo sad to try and UNDO someone else's abuse--
Our purebred just went to be with Jesus yesterday----when she turned on Hubby, it was time. I miss watching her joyful outside play, but when she turned on her ALPHA PERSON---that was his last straw for her---
She was just a year old--but the scars were there--
It is a hard decision, but the chance of biting a child just left NO question in what had to be done.
I will pray that you make the right decision and can find peace with that decision----IT IS NOT EASY!!!!
God bless and guide you...
What about Cesar Millan, I believe he is a well known dog trainer? I'm sure that Bia's nipping is just a habit. I think being a Labrador (one of the gentler breeds) he would be easily trained to stop the nipping. It may be just his way of greeting.
Good luck with it all and I hope a good outcome will eventuate. Love Chris
You don't have small kids do you that could be bitten? Labs definitely don't like people messing with them when they eat.
Muffy :)
Also, I have another whole dimension to my life. I am the full-time caregiver to a very needy adult with disabilities. I have a wonderful husband who helps, but truly, most of the care and management rests on the mom. This can be exhausting. I am 63 years old and have my own physical and medical challenges that are draining. I have a hard time getting enough restful sleep, and rarely have a break. I don't have much time to regenerate. Most of the time I am exhausted. And, Bia is another drain on me. She takes more energy - energy that I just don't have. Our cats fill me up, our parrots fill me up, but at this point, she takes energy away from me.
I have decided I am going to get more help with her training. We are NOT going to her put down, because now I feel there is hope for her. There is more Good about her than wrong. Then when she is better trained, she will add to the family, instead of drain. She is an asset to Ben. We just cannot have her hurt anyone! I could never forgive myself.
http://www.petpartners.org/servicedogtrainerdirectory
Sorry to learn about your concerns.
I am a dog breeder and show exhibitor of smaller dogs - Cavalier King Charles Spaniels - I have indulged in this pleasure for over thirty years - and had previously experienced the companionship of my husbands' Dobermans as well as having owned a Belgian Shepherd as a child, with my very first dog being a stray Dalmation cross bred that had followed me home when my mother was still pushing me along in a stroller. I am not a qualified dog trainer, but with my years of experience with and love of dogs, I might be able to help you a little with a few suggestions.
The end of January can be a time when folk on your side of the world start to feel rather weary and discouraged: the excitement and merry making of Christmas and New Year has waned and winter is at its peak, with spring still seeming too far away to really look forward to and you are weighed down with so many chores and responsibilities and I never cease to be amazed by everything that you manage to do.
Please don't be too harsh or hasty with your judgement of Bia.
Before you disown her or give her a death sentence, please take another look into those deep loving eyes of hers and reconsider your training methods.
Please remember the words in the Bible: "judge not, lest in judging ye also be judged".
Training a dog well is an art which demands a lot of perseverance and learning by the trainer as well as the dog.
Dogs are a little like children who depend on you for guidance, discipline, education, care and nutrition, exercise, fun, happiness and love: one of the differences is that unlike most children who grow up and become "independant", your dog remains dependant on you for his or her whole life; in return, they give you great companionship, their unconditional love, and, if you have treated them fairly, their trust.
From what you have said, she might not be the most intelligent dog in the world and you may not be a skilful enough dog-trainer to turn her into a super service dog, but she has certainly improved a lot and the unconditional love that she and Ben share is a special service in itself.
Please also consider that dog-training is an on-going relationship building exercise that needs to be maintained. It is not just a simple chore that's over with as soon as the dog learns the skills you have taught him or her for the first time; it's more like keeping an athlete in peak condition or making sure a highly skilled surgeon stays good at their job, by frequently refreshing and reinforcing the skills already mastered as well as introducing new skills and keeping their lives balanced with time out for fun and relaxation.
She sounds like she is an exhuberant soul that just loves to be alive and Ben probably reponds well to having someone with such a positive attitude in his life.
With regard to how she takes treats from you, please consider that, because dogs are not blessed with hands that have fingers and thumbs with which to grip something both gently and securely, if you hold that desirable treat out to her by gripping it in your hand or fingers, and she gathers from your handling of the treat that it needs to be gripped, the onely sure way she has of taking hold of it without risking dropping that precious gift is gripping it with her teeth which she will try to use quickly in an effort to prevent losing her prize. HOWEVER, IF YOU INSIST ON HER OBEYING AND HOLDING THE SIT COMMAND IN ODER TO RECEIVE HER TREAT AND YOU OFFER THE SMALL TREAT ON THE PALM OF YOUR OPEN LEVEL HAND IN A WAY THAT THE TREAT IS NOT ABOUT TO FALL OFF YOUR HAND SHE IS MORE LIKELY TO TAKE THE TREAT GENTLY AS SHE PRECEIVES FROM YOUR MANERISM THAT THE TREAT DOES NOT NEED TO BE GRIPPED IN ORDER TO HAVE POSSESSION OF IT and that she needs to completely obey your command and sit calmly for a few seconds in order to receive it. Basically, if the treat is offered without too much excitement by the person offering it, it is more likely to be received calmly. My little dogs watch my eyes and my movements and when they see me reach for the treat box or hear a biscuit being snapped in half, they don't need any additional prompting to sit calmly at attention to receive their treats, but, if one of them does get overexcited and attempts to jump up, they are immediately commanded to sit and do not receive their treat, always on an open palm, until they do.
LIKE MOST OLDER PEOPLE, MOST OLDER DOGS CAN LEARN NEW SKILLS, BUT IT TAKES A BIT LONGER TO LEARN AND IS A BIT HARDER TO REMEMBER, SO TRAINERS OF OLDER DOGS, LIKE TEACHERS OF OLDER PEOPLE, NEED TO HAVE A LOT OF PATIENCE, UNDERSTANDING AND PERSEVERENCE, BUT THE SATISFACTION OF HELPING SOME PERSON OR ANIMAL GAIN AND MAINTAIN NEW SKILLS IS ITS OWN REWARD.
With regard to nipping at people, which to her is probably another way for her to get attention, since you have almost managed to stop her putting her paw up on people, this is undesirable behaviour which does need to be PROMPTLY corrected, but fairly.
Because I don't understand the full details of the circumstances in which she is doing this, it is difficult for me to give you comprehensive advice, but, if it is just her testing to see what she can do or trying to get extra attention, if verbal corrections have already failed, I would then try arming myself and whoever she is likely to this to with a very efficient water pistol and the second she does it I would verbally correct her and give her a good brisk squirt of icy cold water in her face to let her know how displeased you are but you will need to be alongside every one she has the opportunity to nip so that you can discipline her yourself or you will have to make sure every one else she gets the opportunity to nip does exactly the same immediate correction. Training needs to be consistent for it to work; that is the rules must always be clear and obedience of those rules must always be commanded.
If that fails, then you will need to look at other methods. Dogs, like children are all individuals with a multitude of reasons for who they are and how they react to different situations. Successful dog trainers, like teachers sometimes need to assess their trainees carefully, try to understand how their trainees perceive things, and re-adjust their teaching methods to find something that works.
Remember the Good Book points out that we, as Christians cannot serve two masters - well, with dogs, it can be very confusing for them if they have to please too many masters (especially if the masters have slightly different rules.)
Please remember that "dog training" means educating the rest of your household as well as your guests about how to treat Bia, what your "house rules" are, etc.
With regard to her being distracted & chasing after squirrels, etc, she is obviously just wanting to play, but still needs to be taught that when she goes out for a walk on a lead, she must be on her best behaviour.
Letting the lead go when she tugs so she can chase after distractions just teaches her that it is ok to misbehave when she goes out for a walk on the lead. The correct use of a check-chain (usually sold as a choke-chain but put on as a check chain & not put on as a choker chain, which is cruel) should enable you to maintain controll of her on a lead without hurting your arm. If you could find the time to take her to some dog obedience classes, even the basic ones run by your local kennel club which are usually group classes for which the charge is quite small, that should help you with that aspect; and if you keep going to training classes, you should be taught how to teach your dog to "drop" on command, even when she is off leash, which may just save your dog from getting hit by a car, if she slips past you and out the gate one day.
At lot of dog training schools and kennel clubs in Australia make provisions for people that have special needs (and I am guessing the same would be the case where you live) so Ben may be able to participate, too and might even enjoy it - you never know unless you give it a try.
If you don't know how to contact your local kennel club, please try to contact your national Kennel Council who should be able to refer you to one close by.
You may have noticed that when a guide dog goes out with its master, and it is wearing its special harness, it is concentrating all its energy and attention on its work.
Similarly, you need to learn how to teach your dog that when her leash goes on, it is the time when she is "on duty" and it's time for her to be obedient. You may also need to learn more about how to teach your dog to be more interested in watching you and your commands than in every distraction while she is "on duty".
None of this is impossible and you have done such a great job so far, it would be very sad for you to give up now.
If you can't get help with training through a kennel club or professional trainer, then I would suggest that you at least try to find and read the following books:
the first one is not a training book, but is an old book that will give you a good appeciation of how people and animals respond to the combination of their instincts and the way that people brand them (both animals and people) and treat them (both animals and people):
1. Jack London's book, "White Fang".
the other two are dog traing books:
2. "Dog Training Made Easy" by Michael Tucker published by Rigby, who was born in England where he trained RAF police dogs for a short while before embarking on a career training dogs for the Guide Dogs for the Blind in England before migrating to Australia where he continued his career training Guide Dogs for thr Royal Guide Dogs for The Blind Association of Australia and later opened his own dog taining school in Melbourne, Australia. Publishers (Adelaide, Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth, New York, London, Aukland). This book promotes fairly gentle training methods, mainly for dogs who don't have serious personality problems or histories of abuse.
3. "The Koehler Method of Dog Training" by William Koehler (who trained most of movieland's famous dogs) My copy comes from the Howell Book House & was published in USA by Macmillan Publishing Company. (There still are,I think a number of dog training schools whose teachers have been trained by the author and base their classes on his methods). This book promotes firm training, enforced by plenty of praise. This author has had success with re-training dogs with temperament problems, including dogs on "death row". Some of the methods used in some specific cases of very difficult dogs may seem harsh when taken out of context, but if you read through the whole book carefully from the beginning it will make more sense, especially if you consider that, in some cases, strong, but not prolonged torturous discipline, is kinder than the death penalty.
Even if you can get out for some helpful training tuition, these three books are all well worth reading.
Sorry if this reply seems a bit lengthy, but you have asked a number of questions, each of which does not have a short solution and I sincerely hope it has been of some help.
Good luck, lots of cyber-hugs and God Bless.
She was found on a wintry night in Wyoming, starving, had puppies, but no puppies could be found. She is food obsessed.
What do you think about the always hungry problem? Will she ever get over that? Should I sometime just let her eat till she is totally fulll? I think she would vomit and then eat more. She is just a tiny bit overweight, probably. She is muscular and very energetic. A beautiful dog, shiny black fur.
I do so much appreciate all the time you took to share your expertise on dog behavior. Your time was well spent. I'll give Bia a kiss on top of her head for you!
I would never have her put down unless it was absolutely the very last option, and because we felt she was capable of hurting someone.